- Many of us have written our own "ad-hoc" tax programs or spread-sheets, which
need to be re-written each year as the tax code changes, etc..
Spreadsheets don't really do, as the number of entries for a
given category often changes, and they cannot handle all the
conditional calculations required in taxes.
It would be preferable if there were a common library of
routines which would be stable, but which could be used to
quickly describe new tax rules.
- By sharing an open-source tax-program, we might all benefit
by gaining a more complete and correct package.
- There are several commercial tax software packages, but they
are not available for every platform. An open-source package
can be used on all platforms, including Linux, Mac, and Unix in general.
- There are web-based tax filing options, but there are several issues with them.
Some of us do our taxes iteratively as we receive or find statements, not
in one shot. And what personal data is being sent across the net? Who is getting it? Storing it?
How well are they protecting it? Much more information is at stake here than with a simple credit card transaction.
(Social Sec. #, birth date, name, address, income, bank accounts, etc..)
There were hundreds of thousands of identity theft cases last year.
Identity theft is becoming the fastest-growing financial crime in America and
perhaps the fastest-growing crime of any kind in our society.
Experts recommend minimizing the propagation of your personal information. E-file at your own risk.
- As a tax-payer, we expect to understand how our tax is
determined. Neither the government's forms, nor the commercial
tax preparation packages reveal, in a clear way, the tax
equations and the rules used. (As a programmer, I wish to
see the unambiguous expressions or code.
Consider this Fed-1040-For-Programmers.)
- Revealing the tax-law in concise -easily executable- form
enables us to better understand tax consequences of our decisions
throughout the year; not just at tax-time.
- The commercial software packages have become invasive.
They ask questions which do not seem to affect our tax.
On electronic submission, or even paper forms, we have little
visibility as to what information was used or passed.
- Commercial software packages have become bloated -
often requiring the installation of other packages we
may not otherwise wish to do. These
installations may be disruptive of our other software, perhaps
breaking other things on our systems, merely for the purpose
of, for example, adding video tax-wizards, etc..
- The commercial tax packages are awkward. Let's call the
"tax-interview" method "20,000" questions. Partially this is
a tribute to the complexity of our tax code itself, and all the
special cases therein. (For example, I live in a city and I'm
tired of TurboTax asking about my farming practices.)
If you accidentally err in making an entry, they sometimes drop into
a mode which will ask questions from unneeded forms on all future sessions.
Instead, a simple one or two page form, that can be easily
traversed and edited with your favorite text-editor, offers
many advantages, including the ability to view and print a concise
snapshot of your numbers, quick revisions, what-ifs, etc..
- Keep the tax-package simple and modular by being a basic text-oriented
program at its core; no graphical interface complexity. Require only
rudimentary knowledge to understand/modify the code.
(This should not preclude anyone from adding a GUI shell to
access it, or incorporating a GUI later. (Which has now been done.))
* TaxAct offers an over-the-internet form-fillout option, free after registering, but you print your own forms
not for e-filing.
** TurboTax Basic - You may not use the software to prepare tax returns, schedules
or worksheets on a professional basis (ie. for a preparer's or other fee).
*** TaxCut Standard - Use restricted on one computer at a time, and may not share the software
with any other person.
**** TaxAct Online - Limited to Consumer's personal return, does not apply if Consumer uses
TaxACT to prepare returns for persons or entities other than Consumer. (Free to file paper return,
but still asks questions to support electronic filing.)
. . .
Return to OpenTaxSolver